None of what you said contradicts what I said, so I guess nice strawman?

I wrote it to prove that for most people LLMs impair learning.

cost effective

Yes counting the billionaire subsidies. But it’s very costly on the planet.

Ok? Don’t develop parasocial relationships with AI? Don’t use it to skip learning?

Sorry most people do. Few people use heroin to get better from sickness doesn’t mean the majority of people who get their hands on it will abuse it.

4 is anecdotal

Everything you said is anecdotal—that too a very unpopular opinion at that. Lol.

An accountant is going to become less sharp at math

yay we both agree. What has worked in schools is banning a calculator until a student gets proficient in basic arithmetic and math.

That’s what has worked. You can obviously use a calculator to check your answers etc without cheating and get better at math.

But that rarely happens in the real world.

Are you going to criticize every dev for not knowing how to code in assembly?

If you haven’t done even a little bit of assembly then you don’t know the fundamentals of CS—how a processor works etc. Yes I would criticize such devs.

AI can help enable people to learn things they previously could not

They fool you into thinking that you learned a lot. Why don’t you learn something with ai and then take a university exam or apply it in the world with chatgpt off?

I’m sure you’ll fail horribly.