

I think what others said about the writers not thinking it through and the canon being wobbly is the right answer. But I had a thought about what it might be if we were to assume it’s intentional:
Starfleet might have tiered selection processes based on the circumstances of the applicant. As we’re talking about a distant future utopian society, I’m going to assume their education process in Starfleet Academy is good enough that they don’t actually care how many facts Wesley knows. Those can be taught. They’re trying to pick out the best and brightest. But they probably also want to maintain Starfleet’s population as a whole as reasonably representative of the federation so that in times of war they are motivated to fight for the whole federation. They would also have advanced social sciences and are well aware of structural biases like privilege. Taken together, ill conceived entrance requirements could lead to a nepotism/caste of generational spacer families serving in Starfleet. That would be bad for the diplomatic side of the federation as then they’d be more loyal to the institution of Starfleet than the federation, and then the protection of Starfleet amounts to “trust me bro” when negotiating with prospective new member worlds who will want their people serving across Starfleet.
Those taken together means yes it makes sense to have a small and highly restricted and competitive pool for those who are the kids of senior officers serving in prestigious posts and granted unique educational opportunities.


All of those strike me as questions that an asshole would call stupid or is otherwise inappropriate for ask. In order:
It probably has a simple process answer. Some people might read it as a mean spirited question.
Very specific. This one was also crossposted a lot so I wouldn’t read into the community choice.
This is about tv so probably would fit better in a tv community than ask.
OP hasn’t heard of inflation. Though even adjusting for that and “new content” the answer is probably a very simple “yes”. Not much to discuss.
Not sure if this is a can we or should we, but this isn’t really an ask question. The former has a very straightforward answer (yes, it’s the same protocol)
My take is no stupid questions is for questions you’re afraid to ask anywhere else. As long as it’s not hate speech masquerading as a question I ain’t downvoting you, no matter how stupid the question is.