• 0 Posts
  • 73 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 29th, 2023

help-circle





  • I understand that, but again, that’s not the point of my comments. We’re talking about different things and I’m fully aware of lowering fertility rates.

    I don’t know a better way to explain the motivation of my comments than that it is deliberately separating relative population growth (yes it absolutely has to do with fertility rates!) from absolute population growth.

    I’ve been trying to encourage the reader to not think about fertility rates and just be in awe of the sheer amount of humans adding to the total population. The purpose of that thought experiment is to factor in that the growth shouldn’t be solely compared to a number from a previous period, because the growth doesn’t occur in a vacuum: the necessary resources here on Earth don’t grow at the same rate. Simply looking at a growth rate and saying it’s declining draws an extremely misleading picture.

    I, too, genuinely wish you the best in life. However, I have no inclination to be passively aggressive about it.


  • Fertility rates, while interesting and relevant, were not what my comments were about.

    My first comment made an observation that last year alone, we added the equivalent of the current population of the United Kingdom to the planet, and we’ve been doing that every year, for the past 70 years. (As an aside, I argue that the net addition is “significantly more.”)

    My second comment remarked on the skewed perspective of looking at relative growth rates, which is why I specifically called out the human population in absolute numbers.

    I fail to see how anything I’ve said is incorrect but I’m open to the feedback.




  • It’s odd to bring percentages into it as the other factors of the equation aren’t growing at the same rate. In fact, they are decreasing.

    The absolute number of people continues to increase steadily, consuming more and more and more of the finite resources we have.

    There are more humans on this planet today than have ever been on this planet in the past, and the same will be true for as long as our projections can reliably predict, and we have no intention to reduce that number.

    I don’t think the word “slow” has any place in describing this growth unless one wishes to deliberately obfuscate it by using an exponential scale.