CrocodilloBombardino

  • 3 Posts
  • 68 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: April 7th, 2025

help-circle










  • this article is so stupid.

    The new socialists thus want the state to dictate the prices of many goods and services, especially essentials such as food and rent. Where money is required it will come, almost exclusively, by squeezing the very wealthiest. It is a form of retail politics that appeals not to notions of the common good, as in prior waves of socialism, but to people’s narrow self-interest. Lower my rent! Cut my bills! Give me free buses! Protect my job! The solutions are naive, and often unworkable. But the message is so simple, and so attractive, that this Gen-Z socialism is gaining adherents across the democratic world.

    None of that is socialism. it’s social democracy (aka gentler capitalism) at best. lower rent, lower bills, free buses, and job protections are not “selfish”, they apply to everyone.






  • hm. so im hearing that you’re in favor of freedom to engage with, change, or not engage with traditions. This is the same position as is held by people who call themselves liberals and especially leftists of various types.

    you are religious, but so are people all across the political spectrum, so that doesn’t require conservatism on its own. you also don’t seem to push your religion on anyone else.

    you are clearly worried about the planet and ecology but don’t tie it to a specific ethnic group, like when the right takes it up as an excuse to exclude others (e.g. Malthusian perspectives, ecofascism). an earnestly ecological outlook I’ve seen mostly in the center and on the left.

    I think your positions make you more of a leftist. maybe you’ve been shown the left or individual leftists in a bad light… that happens a lot in media. or maybe you live in a former Soviet bloc country, which makes the left in general and “socialism” especially look bad (though I’d argue the ussr wasn’t doing socialism).

    if you’re curious at all, I’d be glad to give you some materials on leftist positions as they actually are and not as they are portrayed by the right and the center.


  • It means to conserve the ways that your peoples historically had, not a specific universal way.

    So then everyone is essentially trapped in the traditions of the family they were born into? The details here can be complicated: Do children of blended families get to choose from among the cultures of their parents, or what about children in group homes or foster care? Should we not have the freedom to replace or modify the traditions we don’t find meaningful, assuming we are not harming anyone else?

    I grew up with a sense of resentment towards traditions i grew up with because they were done in a rote, check-the-box way. i saw no meaning in them. maybe a version more relevant to modern times would have given me more to appreciate.


  • Hey, good faith reply here. Conservatism doesn’t simply mean “to conserve”: it has different, specific political meanings depending on what country or political system you’re referring to. Not only that, but plenty of political movements use labels that are more about sounding good than a truly accurate description of what they are. For example, Murray Rothbard deliberately stole the term “libertarian” (for American right-wing “libertarians”) from its original connection to anarchism and libertarian socialism.

    Also can you clarify your point about “traditional values”? As you said, different cultures and different time periods have had different traditions, so which ones are we conserving? If the answer is “any or all of them”, then isn’t that the same as “do whatever you like”? If the answer is a specific set of values, why those? That’s not meant to be a gotcha, I’m legit interested in where you’re coming from.

    Thank you for explicitly banning nazis, fascists, and similar groups, along with other forms of bigotry. They are a plague on us all and have no place in any political camp.